QuantumLight
  • Blog

When is enough, enough?

11/30/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture
Picture
​                  While the tourism industry is currently being measured by economic indicators – tourist arrivals and tourist receipts – we are not getting the real picture. This is the sad reality about our industry.  The price that we are paying for the volume of tourists and the industry’s contribution to GNP is NOT part of the equation.  We are clueless as to the crimes, pollution, cultural dilution, health issues and  ecosystem damage that tourism has brought, in the name of tourist arrivals and the so called "economic prosperity" for the few.  So, how do we know when the volume is enough? Do we go for unlimited increase in tourist arrivals?  When do we start controlling?  Or, do we even control at all? 
 
                  Many LGUs have the misconception that  the more tourists there are, the better.  Sadly few of our industry managers are aware of the concept of “Doxey’s Irritation Index Model”.   The concept simply says that tourist volume affects how local residents of a destination feel about tourism.   Although destinations would have  varying thresholds and tolerances, the idea is that the increase in the volume of tourists affects how the local population feels about tourists in general. The model describes 4 stages  that are progressively equivalent to the increase in volume and how the people feel about the presence of tourists in their community. 

1. Euphoria – This is when visitors start to trickle in and makes the local residents realize that there  is something special about their place and culture.  Often, locals have a different perception about themselves and their community because they see     their surroundings everyday.  When somebody from the outside starts talking about the place in a very positive way, this opens  up their minds and makes them appreciate  their resources and assets more.  At this stage,  the benefit is more about sense of pride instead of money. 
​

2.  Apathy – When engagement between tourists and locals becomes more formal, visitors are taken for granted and the focus is more about economic gain and personal benefit.  This stage shifts the mindset of the community from “togetherness” to “each his own”. At this point the bayanihan spirit goes through a natural death. 

3. Irritation -  This stage may be described as  booming economically, but also declining as far as environmental  and social integrity.  Due to increased volume of tourists and the development frenzy, social and environmental problems start to rise.  Crimes become more serious and more frequent.  Irresponsible behavior  from tourists, as well as locals are  daily occurrences. Policies may be  in place, but ethics and professionalism are not the norm.  When  local culture is diluted, locals tend to react negatively.  Even those who are directly deriving economic benefit may admit that the community is no longer how it was before tourism developed.  It is at this stage that saturation is reached, but sadly managers tend to address the situation by increasing infrastructure (more hotels, better access) and increasing promotions to masked what is actually happening.  They resort to “suicidal” strategies instead of limiting growth. This may herald a point of no return.

4. Antagonism -  When the industry shows indications that it is  chaotic and uncontrolled, locals tend to protest openly and express their displeasure  and irritation over what is happening.  A good example would be Barcelona, Venice and Boracay.  At this point managers increase promotions or re-brand the destination, in order to offset deteriorating reputation. Despite what's going on, it is still "business as usual".  

Picture
             Why then do we need to know this concept?  There is a point in the industry’s life cycle when   it becomes very expensive, or even utterly impossible  to restore  what has been destroyed.  A natural environment that has been damaged ,or a culture that has been  diluted may  not be brought back to its original state, at least not in our lifetime.  It would be a shame that something that took millions of years to create (such as a natural landscape or an ecosystem)  or generations to  mold (such as a local culture), will be destroyed in a span of 15 to 20 years. Remember that all humans (including tourists)  create an  ecological footprint on a daily basis.  Hence, the more people there are in a specific place, the greater the impact. 
 
              Planning responsibly is the key towards ensuring that a local tourism industry has enough safety nets to avoid the usual traps of uncontrolled development.  For a beautiful country like the Philippines, there is just too much that  could  be lost,  if tourism is  simply allowed  to happen and without any means of control. 

          To learn more about tourism planning and how destinations can be created to last for many generations, follow the link:     
http://suievents.com/philippine-ecotourism-101


0 Comments
    Picture

    Author

    This blog is about the reflections, opinions and observations  of tourism planner Chen Reyes-Mencias. 

    Archives

    February 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.